Payroll Company Assessment Tools for Business Owners

Mar 24, 2020

IBA, as the premier business brokerage firm in the Pacific Northwest, is firmly established as a respected professional service firm in the legal, accounting, banking, mergers & acquisitions, real estate, and financial planning communities.  Periodically, we will post guest blogs from professionals with knowledge to share for the good of owners of privately held companies & family owned businesses. The following blog article has been provided by Eric Moore of Accounting Solution Partners (

Payroll Company Assessment Tools for Business Owners

While some small business owners simply use a payroll software to manage payments to employees, others use full-service payroll providers. The decision usually hinges on cost of services and the scope of the work needed. Businesses with just a few employees and a small budget will typically choose to manage payroll themselves using an add-on that works with the accounting system or bookkeeping platform that they are already utilizing.

However, businesses with more employees and/or more sophisticated needs, will often outsource payroll to save time and reduce the likelihood of errors. ​

The second quarter is the most common time for businesses to switch payroll providers because it allows ample time for implementation, ensuring that year-end close is not affected. With the prime season for changing providers quickly approaching, many business owners and HR managers are doing their research now to find a better payroll solution. The questions on their mind are:

  • Is our current payroll system meeting our needs?
  • Will it continue to meet our needs in the future as the business grows?
  • What should I look for in a new payroll company? What should I steer clear of?
  • Which features and services do I really need?
  • What kinds of questions should I ask when evaluating providers?

As you research payroll solutions use this provider checklist to guide your search efforts.

Services Provided 

Scope of Work

While payroll providers will typically all offer standard services like payroll processing, reporting, and direct deposit, there can be variation in the types of supplemental services that are included. In some instances, a provider may offer tiered pricing services to provide additional services at a higher price point. Ensure an apples-to-apples comparison based on included services and available features before analyzing pricing, payment terms, and other factors.

Determine whether a provider’s offerings will suit your business based on how many employees it can handle and how many users are permitted. Some small business software simply cannot handle the demands of larger companies, while others can be modified to do so at an additional cost.

One of the most common service questions that owners and managers ask is how payroll taxes are handled. Discern whether the payroll provider will supply the information needed for the business to pay its own payroll taxes or whether the provider will handle it on the business’s behalf. Some providers just calculate owed taxes and make this information accessible to the business, others may supply required paperwork with this information included, and other will handle the entire process.

Ask questions to understand how each provider approaches this topic.

  • What is included in the software?
  • Is the number of employees capped? If so, what is the cost of adding additional employees?
  • How many users are allowed? What is the cost of adding additional users?
  • Are some features only included on premium plans?
  • Are payroll taxes filed or just calculated?


In addition to optional software updates and mandatory version upgrades, items like the payroll tax table will require regular updates. Inquire about how often these updates are needed and what the process of updating them looks like. With some software, updates occur automatically, while others will need to be manually initiated. Some providers will handle updates and upgrades to ensure smooth functionality, while others expect the client to handle these administrative aspects. If software does not automatically update the tax table, it is not operating on real-time information, which can lead to tax calculation errors, making it a crucial area to consider.

  • How does the payroll tax table get updated? How often is it updated?
  • Who is responsible for installing software updates and version upgrades?


Accompanying the service details is the price and duration of the service agreement. Some providers will require that clients sign a contract for six months, a year, or even two years. Others will forgo the contract in favor of offering a discount for prepaying for service. Sometimes the software being utilized will have ongoing fees to maintain usage or renew the license as well. Understand what your contractual obligations are, what you can expect the total cost to be, and any fees that may be associated with getting out of the contract early.

  • Is there a contract to sign?
  • Is there a discount for prepaying for the year?
  • Does the software have a license that will expire and need to be repurchased?

Potential for Growth

Make a note of payroll providers that offer advanced payroll and benefits services that your business does not need now. Remember that as your business grows, its payroll needs will likely follow suit. Try to forecast where your business will be later this year or next year to avoid having to switch providers again as your business continues to evolve.

  • Can the provider’s offerings grow with your business?



Ask whether payroll software or a payroll provider integrates with other platforms and apps to make running your business easier. Determine how you will leverage other technology to bolster the provider’s offerings. More robust integrations provide additional flexibility, decreasing labor costs and reducing payroll errors.

If your business employs hourly staff or contractors, ensure the provider includes or can integrate with time tracking software and other relevant HR functions for streamlined operations.

  • Which integrations are offered?
  • Is there an API to modify the software for use with unsupported platforms?
  • Is there a mobile app to assist in running your business on the go?


Know what kind of support is provided and find a provider that offers whatever level of support best matches your needs. Less tech savvy owners and managers will likely want person-to-person support channels like phone and live chat help, while more experienced personnel may only need self-help resources like tutorials and user forums. Read online reviews to find out what users are saying about the provider’s support related to courteousness, wait times, and resolving problems to determine if the support is valuable, especially if there is an added fee for premium support.

  • Do tutorials and resources exist to help during setup?
  • Is support provided via phone, email, or live chat? Is it helpful?
  • Is premium support available?

Business Profile


Research what current and former customers have said about each provider to understand what to expect from a client’s standpoint. Reading reviews can help uncover trends to understand whether the company is on an upward or downward trajectory. For instance, do not shy away from providers that previously had a reputation of providing lackluster customer service if it appears that they have taken the steps to improve.

  • Are the provider’s current and past customers satisfied?
  • What do online reviews intimate about the provider’s future?


Some industries have unique payroll needs. Finding a payroll provider that is tailored to handle those specific challenges and idiosyncrasies from the beginning can save time and headaches later. It is always best to use a solution that is meant for a specific application rather than trying to adapt something else, which is why restaurants and retail stores, for instance, will look for payroll providers that cater to their individual industries.

  • Does the provider have experience in relevant industries?

Business Lifecycle Stage

A payroll provider should meet your business where it is. Small business will typically benefit from using a provider that is aligned with their budget restrictions and time constraints. Similarly, high-growth startups should seek a payroll provider that can efficiently handle big hiring pushes.

  • Is the provider experienced in working with clients in your business’s life stage?

If you have questions relating to the content of this article, Eric Moore of Accounting Solutions Partners would welcome the opportunity to answer them.  Mr. Moore can be reached at (425) 492-1901 or

IBA, the Pacific Northwest’s premier business brokerage firm since 1975, is available as an information resource to the media, business brokerage, mergers & acquisitions, and real estate communities on subjects relevant to the purchase & sale of privately held companies and family owned businesses.  IBA is recognized as one of the best business brokerage firms in the nation based on its long track record of successfully negotiating “win-win” business sale transactions in environments of full disclosure employing “best practices”.